Houghton Mifflin Beyond The BookWell-known education experts offer commentary on current events, timely issues, and trends in education.
Comment on This ArticleHomeNewsSuccess StoriesLeadershipStrategiesOpinionsAbout Use-Newsletter
Share your reactions to this article.*
E-mail:*
Title:*
State:*
By submitting my comment, I accept the Terms and Conditions of Use. I understand that my e-mail address will be kept private.
* Indicates required field
Related Links & Resources
Social Studies/History
Tools
Printer-friendly VersionPrinter-friendly Version
E-mail to a ColleagueE-mail to a Colleague
Republish ArticleRepublish Article
Let Us Know
Is there an education issue or trend you'd like to discuss?  Let us know

Expert Opinions

An Argument to Engage Students in the Political Process
by Robert Dallek, Ph.D.

Robert Dallek is a renowned presidential historian and senior consultant for McDougal Littell American History.

Young Americans are notoriously indifferent to political participation. Where only about half the electorate turns out to vote in presidential elections, the percentage of those between eighteen and thirty who go to the polls is significantly smaller. State, county, and local elections command even less attention. In a recent Democratic Party primary for a U.S. Senate nomination in Virginia, for example, just 4 percent of eligible voters cast ballots—one can only imagine how few young people were part of that shrunken group.

Voting in America is seen not as a privilege, but a right that is taken for granted and only exercised by youngsters when some issue strikes them as directly touching their lives. And such topics of concern are few: taxes, Social Security, and health insurance, for example, seem of little consequence to teens and twenty-somethings still in school and on the family payroll. Questions of military service can get the attention of young people, but then only males—it has not been a matter of concern to women who have traditionally been excluded from selective service. With a volunteer military since the 1970s, recent generations of first-time voters see little reason to worry about elected officials passing conscription measures. Not even the Iraq war has brought the possibility of required military service back into focus.

So, is there any way to educate youngsters to see voting as a civic responsibility they should take seriously? Short of mandatory voting, which is a feature of Australian democracy, for example, prospects for a new era of heightened voter participation by youngsters seems bleak.

Despite this, I believe that educators across America—at all levels between kindergarten and twelfth grade—can press the case for wider involvement in the country's democratic processes with the hope of making a difference.

Rigorous student election processes for class and school-wide officers can get youngsters more involved. Every school has issues that are of greater importance to students than those the general electorate faces in periodic elections. Everything from dress codes to team sports and afterschool activities genuinely interest students. An early recognition that they can institutionalize their preferences through open discussions and voting is an advance in the effort to educate young people to the virtues of democracy and the power of the ballot box.

As a professional historian, I am biased about the usefulness of U.S. history classes in stimulating student interest in the country's political institutions. Discussions about early American history, the Revolution, battles over the Articles of Confederation, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights can be salutary in promoting student awareness of the cost in blood and treasure to secure what young people now take for granted. There is an even more compelling lesson in the blood shed to protect traditional freedoms against authoritarianism during World Wars I and II and the Cold War. There is an equally instructive example in the country's internal struggles to expand traditional freedoms to African Americans: First, through a Civil War that ended slavery, and then through a civil rights movement in which people lost their lives to overcome racism and assure equal opportunity for all Americans, regardless of race or gender. Surely, such a recounting of the national experience can inspire young people not to be casual about traditional rights and to perform their civic duty and vote.

I think that certain national holidays—like President's Day, Martin Luther King, Jr.'s Birthday, Memorial Day, Veteran's Day, and Thanksgiving—are also useful devices for compelling attention to the country's democratic traditions. The great events of the twentieth century in which repressive systems of governance, particularly Nazism and Communism, and their crimes against humanity, especially the Holocaust, can stand as object lessons in any effort to show youngsters that liberty and the rule of law are sacred doctrines worthy of study and defense. These are powerful tools for reminding students that our freedoms—of speech, press, assembly, and to vote—are not universally available; that in fact, Americans are privileged citizens of the world who should never take their rights for granted.

Finally, I believe there is no substitute for bringing elected officials—school board members, city councilmen, county sheriffs, state legislators, judges—into civics and social studies classes to discuss the thought process of running for and experience of serving in elected office. It is instructive because it gives students a glimpse of what public officials do, and underscores why it is important to vote for honest, effective public servants.

I am certain that teachers in every grade and discipline can find ways to bring the country's democratic traditions into the classroom. It is as worthy a mission as anything any of us who instruct students do. There should be state and national awards for teachers who are best at creating a sense of civic responsibility among the country's youngsters. Foundations should be encouraged to promote such awards and provide prize money to those who win them.


Printer-friendly VersionPrinter-friendly VersionE-mail to a ColleagueE-mail to a ColleagueRepublish ArticleRepublish Article

NOTICE:
All opinions expressed in these articles and in any comments are those of the authors, and the use of these articles on this site is not intended as an endorsement of Houghton Mifflin Company, its divisions, its employees, or its products. The views, organizations, and companies featured in Beyond the Book are not necessarily endorsed by Houghton Mifflin Company.
Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions of Use
Copyright ©  Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved.